Is there a goodwill or consignment shop on St. Croix?
There is the Animal Shelter Flea Market near the Richmond Post Office (down the road right beside Olympic Car Rental and the Women's Coalition Thrift Store. I think the estate is called Work and Rest, but not sure. It's the road you take as you leave Cost-U-Less and head back toward C'sted, in the area of Quinn House and Brass Key.
There is also Cabana Girl consignment in Gallows Bay for nice clothes and Uniquities in Peter's Rest for better quality furniture and house wares.