Any NY Style pizza ...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Any NY Style pizza in stx?

(@stt007)
Posts: 475
Reputable Member
Topic starter
 

If so, which is the best and are any around christiansted?

 
Posted : December 20, 2012 5:28 pm
(@stiphy)
Posts: 956
Prominent Member
 

Napolean's is very good (IMO) NY style Pizza. Get slices though, just like if you were in NY they are better as they get the "reheat" treatment for a crispy crust. They are in Peter's Rest across from Cost U Less or Fredericksted. They had a C'sted location but unfortunately it closed.

And while it's not very NY their seafood pizza is awesome.

Sean

 
Posted : December 20, 2012 6:03 pm
(@susan56)
Posts: 147
Estimable Member
 

I thought the little pizza stand at Plaza Extra was great!

 
Posted : December 20, 2012 6:23 pm
(@sheiba)
Posts: 483
Reputable Member
 

Havent had any pizza that stands up to new york or chicago but palms at pelican cove (served at the bar, not the dining room) is pretty good at a great price of $12.00 and you cant beat the view.

 
Posted : December 20, 2012 8:02 pm
(@InnAtPelicanHeights)
Posts: 319
Reputable Member
 

Sadly, you will be disappointed on St Croix for NY style. Every once in awhile, you will get one that will be good at several places, however, you will go again, and it wont be like the last one.

 
Posted : December 21, 2012 12:52 am
(@gonetropo)
Posts: 428
Reputable Member
 

Just went up and got a pizza at Napoleans last night...one of the worst pizzas we have had. Dominos is better!

Out vote on STX goes to the Lost Dog in Fredricksted...hands down.

 
Posted : December 21, 2012 11:39 am
(@vicanuck)
Posts: 2935
Famed Member
 

No, no...you all have it wrong.

The absolute BEST pizza on the island is at Blue Water Terrace.

They offer all thier pizzas as either thick crust, a thin crust or calzone.

I had not had one until a few months ago and now we go there every week for a delicious pie.

They are so big that we always have plenty to take home for next day eating.

I also would vote for Tutto Bene for their thin crust as second place.

Give them both a try.

 
Posted : December 21, 2012 11:41 am
(@speee1dy)
Posts: 8871
Illustrious Member
 

i used to like flat iron grill, but they closed. and susan, i too like the pizza at plaza.

 
Posted : December 21, 2012 12:20 pm
(@loungestx)
Posts: 191
Estimable Member
 

Pizza mare used to be across from the park near scooner. That really was ny style but alas no more. Cultured pellican was good but i havnt been in quite a while.
I am just a wealth of outdated knowledge!

 
Posted : December 22, 2012 12:01 am
(@speee1dy)
Posts: 8871
Illustrious Member
 

me too

 
Posted : December 22, 2012 12:50 am
(@Skullwithhair)
Posts: 36
Eminent Member
 

I agree with Blue Water having good pie. East End Pizza at the Divi is really good...if its still open. Been off island for a year

 
Posted : December 22, 2012 11:31 am
(@stt007)
Posts: 475
Reputable Member
Topic starter
 

Tried Tutto Bene last night w sausage, prosciutto and olives last night. Mucho goodo! Tx for the recommendation!

 
Posted : December 22, 2012 3:55 pm
(@AandA2VI)
Posts: 2294
Noble Member
 

We had pizza serveral times on our PMV from Lost Dogs too, we were told to order the Tinee special and it was amazing! I'm sure I spelled Tinee wrong, I think it's the chefs name.

 
Posted : December 22, 2012 5:33 pm
(@bancroft)
Posts: 11
Active Member
 

Off the Wall in Cane Bay has good pizza, can't beat the ambiance and the view either

 
Posted : January 5, 2013 12:02 pm
(@jostvandog)
Posts: 206
Estimable Member
 

Yes East End Pizza at the Divi is still there and I love it.

 
Posted : January 5, 2013 12:16 pm
(@speee1dy)
Posts: 8871
Illustrious Member
 

i dont always like their pizza. sometimes its good and sometimes its not

 
Posted : January 5, 2013 12:37 pm
(@vicanuck)
Posts: 2935
Famed Member
 

Off The Wall pizza is great too...I've had it many times and always enjoyed the food and location.

 
Posted : January 5, 2013 1:17 pm
(@robbystx)
Posts: 157
Estimable Member
 

My vote is for Blue Water Terrace, the pizza is excellent!!

 
Posted : January 5, 2013 2:27 pm
(@SunnyCaribe)
Posts: 495
Reputable Member
 

Off The Wall pizza is great too...I've had it many times and always enjoyed the food and location.

Better eat before you go, though.

 
Posted : January 5, 2013 10:26 pm
(@Linda_J)
Posts: 3919
Famed Member
 

Sunny, what do you mean? We always enjoyed the food at Off the Wall.

 
Posted : January 7, 2013 1:05 pm
(@vicanuck)
Posts: 2935
Famed Member
 

Sunny might be referring to the length of time it takes to get your order at Off the Wall.

I've experienced that too but don't go there to rush now.

The delay in my pizza helps me drink more.

 
Posted : January 7, 2013 5:56 pm
(@CityGuy)
Posts: 103
Estimable Member
 

Was a cop in NYC, lived on pizza and donuts, there is no such thing as NY Style pizza in or on STX. Not even close!

 
Posted : January 7, 2013 6:36 pm
(@stt007)
Posts: 475
Reputable Member
Topic starter
 

I hear ya cityguy. how hard can it be?

 
Posted : January 8, 2013 3:20 am
(@vicanuck)
Posts: 2935
Famed Member
 

Can you describe a NY style pizza? What are its attributes?

 
Posted : January 8, 2013 11:32 am
(@bobnq3x)
Posts: 7
Active Member
 

Red-grease-on-cardboard crust, you have to be able to fold it. Never could understand the attraction, myself.

😎

We're partial to the pizza at Castaways in Solitude. Not NY style, but Vinny is a very good pizza designer. I live just down the hill from Blue Water and would rather drive the mile to Castaways instead for pizza. For us, it is superior in every way.

Cheers,

Bob

 
Posted : January 9, 2013 12:15 pm
Page 1 / 2
Search this website Type then hit enter to search
Close Menu